Countertop Pros and Cons


Confused about what countertops are best for your kitchen? You’re not alone. From style to color to durability to cost, there are a lot of factors to consider. Here are the pros and cons of some of the most popular counter materials.

**Please note that prices can vary so use the prices below as a guideline only.


Pros – Low price point, wide variety of colors and styles, and durable enough to withstand everyday use.

Cons – Not as durable as natural stone, not heat resistant, and can be difficult to clean.

Cost  $10 to $30 per square foot, installed.

Laminate Counter

Engineered Stone (Quartz)

Pros – Low maintenance, doesn’t need to be sealed, heat & scratch proof, and easy to customize. Currently one of the most popular materials on the market.

Cons – May show visible seams where pieces meet. This can be avoided by using continuous pieces.

Cost – $35 to $100 per square foot, installed.

Scott McGillivray Home Bar Counter


Pros – Looks luxurious and is available in a wide variety of colors.

Cons – Soft and porous meaning is scratches and stains very easily.

Cost – $50 to $150 per square foot, installed.

Marble Counters


Pros – Requires very little maintenance and is stain, heat and water resistant when sealed.

Cons – Very heavy and needs to be well supported, can chip or crack if the material is too thin, and final colors can vary from samples.

Cost – $35 to $200 per square foot, installed.

Granite Counters


Pros – Tough, heat-resistant, and stain-resistant.

Cons – Very heavy and difficult to install.

Cost – $75 to $125 per square foot, installed.

Concrete Counter

Stainless Steel

Pros – Durable, heat-resistant, and high-end commercial kitchen look.

Cons – Crumbs, spills and fingerprints show up very easily plus it scratches and dents easily.

Cost – $75 to $150 per square foot, installed.

Stainless Steel Counter

Butcher Block

Pros – Affordable, warm look and feel, and naturally anti-bacterial.

Cons – Not very heat or water resistant, marks easily, and requires regular maintenance.

Cost – $35 to $70 per square foot, installed.

Butcher Block Counter

Countertop Tips


For more information about making your countertop work with your backsplash please check out How to Choose a Backsplash and Counter.



Top photo and Quartz photo courtesy of HGTV Canada’s Moving the McGillivrays, concrete counter photo via DIY Network, stainless steel photo courtesy of iStock/seanoriordan. All other photos courtesy of Skit Inc.

« Back to Articles

Relevant Articles

  • How to Tile a Backsplash For Beginners+
  • Kitchen Remodel Do’s and Don’ts+
  • Get the Look: Century Kitchen+
  • Storage Solutions: Kitchen Islands+
  • Countertop Pros and Cons+
  • 5 Reasons to Choose Quartz for Your Kitchen+
  • How to Choose a Kitchen Backsplash+
  • Want VS Need – An R2R Kitchen Case Study+
  • Style Guide – Andrew’s Kitchen+


Don’t be afraid to call your municipality’s permit office to discuss your project. They can help you understand the process and make it run smoother.